Switching accountants feels like switching banks—inconvenient, time-consuming, and honestly, a bit scary. Most New Jersey business owners stick with the same CPA for years, even when that relationship costs them tens of thousands in unnecessary taxes.
But here's the truth: your accountant should be saving you more money than they cost. If they're not proactively reducing your tax bill, helping you structure your business properly, or responding when you need them, you're not just paying for mediocre service—you're leaving real money on the table.
After helping hundreds of profitable small businesses in Monmouth County and Ocean County transition to proactive tax planning, we've identified seven undeniable red flags that signal it's time to make a change.
If your only interaction with your CPA happens during tax season, you don't have a strategic partner—you have a tax filing service.
What this costs you: Reactive tax preparation means you discover your tax bill after the year ends, when there's virtually nothing left to do about it. Business owners who only file taxes without year-round planning routinely overpay by $20,000 to $50,000 annually.
What proactive service looks like: Your CPA should meet with you at least quarterly, ideally before Q4, to review your financial performance and implement tax reduction strategies before December 31st. This includes adjusting estimated payments, timing equipment purchases, maximizing retirement contributions, and deploying other strategic moves that only work when planned in advance.
Real-world example: A roofing contractor in Monmouth County came to us paying $87,000 in taxes despite making similar revenue to the previous year. Their old accountant never called to discuss estimated payments or suggest year-end strategies. After switching to quarterly planning meetings, we identified $43,000 in tax savings for the following year—more than three times our annual fee.
Are you operating as a sole proprietor or LLC when you should be an S-Corp? This is one of the most expensive mistakes we see, and it's entirely preventable.
What this costs you: Business owners in the wrong entity structure pay an extra 15.3% in self-employment taxes on their entire profit. For a business netting $200,000, that's $30,600 in unnecessary taxes every single year.
What proactive service looks like: An experienced CPA reviews your entity structure annually and recommends S-Corp conversion when it makes financial sense. The S-Corp structure allows you to split your income between reasonable salary (subject to payroll taxes) and distributions (not subject to self-employment tax), creating immediate savings.
The conversation should happen proactively, not when you ask about it. If you're profitable and your accountant has never brought up entity optimization, they're costing you money.
Learn more: S-Corp 101: Is It Time to Restructure Your Business?
Receiving IRS notices for underpayment penalties? Getting shocked by a $40,000 tax bill you weren't expecting? These are symptoms of an accountant who isn't managing your quarterly estimated tax payments.
What this costs you: Underpayment penalties add 3-8% on top of what you already owe, and unexpected tax bills create cash flow nightmares. Even worse, many business owners overpay throughout the year and give the government an interest-free loan—money that could be working in your business.
What proactive service looks like: Your CPA should calculate and adjust your estimated tax payments quarterly based on actual business performance, not just last year's figures. This means you land the plane on December 31st owing close to zero and getting no refund—the optimal outcome. We help clients in Newark, Edison, and throughout Central New Jersey manage quarterly payments strategically through their payroll services, adjusting as business conditions change.
Does your accountant go radio silent outside of tax season? Do emails go unanswered for weeks? That's not a legitimate "busy season" excuse—it's poor service.
What this costs you: When time-sensitive tax questions arise or you need guidance on a major business decision, delays cost you opportunities. Missing deadlines, making uninformed choices about equipment purchases, or failing to implement mid-year strategies all chip away at your profitability.
What proactive service looks like: Your CPA firm should respond within 24-48 hours year-round. You should have access to your team when you need guidance on hiring decisions, major purchases, real estate investments, or any financial move that impacts your taxes.
At Shore Financial Planning, responsiveness is non-negotiable. When you get a notice from the IRS, you shouldn't panic—you should forward it to your CPA and know they'll handle it. When you're considering buying a $75,000 piece of equipment, you should be able to call and understand the tax implications before signing.
Related: Tax Planning vs. Tax Prep: Understanding the Difference
If your accountant isn't providing clean, accurate monthly bookkeeping, they can't deliver meaningful tax planning. You can't make strategic decisions based on guesswork.
What this costs you: Without accurate financials, you're flying blind. You don't know if you're actually profitable, which services or products drive revenue, where you're overspending, or what your cash position looks like. Poor bookkeeping also means missed deductions and creates audit risk.
What proactive service looks like: Professional monthly bookkeeping services keep your financials current, accurate, and organized. This creates the foundation for effective tax planning and gives you the financial clarity to make better business decisions.
For businesses that let bookkeeping slide for months or years, accounting cleanup services get everything caught up and compliant. Once clean, staying current is exponentially easier than catching up later.
We see this frequently with HVAC contractors, landscaping companies, and plumbing contractors who've been focused on growing their business but neglected the back office.
Does your accountant work with hundreds of random clients across every possible industry? Or do they specialize in businesses like yours?
What this costs you: Generic CPAs miss industry-specific deductions, don't understand seasonal cash flow patterns, and can't benchmark your performance against similar businesses. They treat a dental practice the same as a trucking company, missing critical strategies unique to your industry.
What proactive service looks like: Specialized accountants know the ins and outs of your industry. For contractors, this means understanding job costing, progress billing, equipment depreciation strategies, and seasonal revenue fluctuations. For healthcare practices, it's knowing how to structure associate compensation, navigate medical expense deductions, and optimize retirement plans for high earners.
Shore Financial Planning specializes in:
When your CPA understands your business model deeply, they identify opportunities generic accountants miss.
Has your accountant ever discussed cost segregation for your commercial property? Retirement plans beyond a simple SEP IRA? Hiring your children to shift income? Medical reimbursement plans? If not, you're working with someone focused on compliance, not strategy.
What this costs you: Advanced strategies create substantial savings. A cost segregation study on a $1 million property can accelerate $200,000+ in depreciation deductions. A properly structured small business retirement plan can shelter $60,000+ annually while building wealth. These aren't fringe strategies—they're standard tools for proactive CPAs.
What proactive service looks like: Your CPA should proactively present strategies tailored to your situation. Not every strategy fits every business, but if you've never had the conversation, your accountant isn't doing their job.
These strategies require upfront work and ongoing implementation support, which is why transactional accountants avoid them. Strategic CPAs embrace them because they deliver measurable value.
Related reading:
Let's be clear: switching accountants is inconvenient. There's paperwork, transitioning your books, getting someone new up to speed on your business. It's easier to stick with what you know.
But convenience is expensive when it costs you $30,000, $50,000, or more every year.
Consider this: if you're a construction business owner in Brick, NJ netting $300,000 annually and you're in the wrong entity structure, missing depreciation strategies, and not maximizing retirement contributions, you could easily be overpaying by $60,000+ per year. Over a decade, that's $600,000—money that belongs in your pocket, not the government's.
The businesses that switch to proactive tax planning typically experience 3-5x return on investment in the first year alone. Our guarantee reflects this: if our tax planning doesn't identify savings greater than our fee, we refund your money.
You deserve an accounting partner who:
This is the baseline standard of service for business owners with six or seven-figure revenues. If your current CPA isn't delivering this, you're subsidizing their inefficiency with your tax overpayments.
Switching to Shore Financial Planning is straightforward:
The entire process typically takes 30-60 days, and most clients see measurable results within their first year.
Shore Financial Planning works with business owners throughout Central New Jersey, including:
Whether you're in Long Branch, Asbury Park, Jersey City, or anywhere in the region, we provide the same high-touch, proactive service.
If you recognized three or more of these red flags, it's time for a conversation.
Schedule a complimentary strategy session to review your tax situation. We'll identify specific opportunities to reduce your taxes and determine whether we're a good fit. Even if we're not, you'll walk away with clarity about what's possible.
The reluctance to change is understandable. But staying comfortable with mediocre service costs real money—money that could fund your retirement, grow your business, or provide security for your family.
Your accountant should be increasing your bottom line without you having to increase revenue. If they're not, you're paying for the wrong service.
Contact Shore Financial Planning or call (732) 704-8982 to schedule your strategy session.
Shore Financial Planning serves profitable small businesses throughout New Jersey with proactive tax planning, accounting, and bookkeeping services. We specialize in contractors, healthcare practices, and service businesses, and guarantee our tax planning will save you more than our fees or we refund your money.